11
Padres Go All-In: Blockbuster Deadline Plan to Fix Every Roster Hole
The Padres at the Trade Deadline: A Simple Guide to What Might Happen
The Big Picture: Good, But Not Good Enough (Yet)
Imagine the San Diego Padres are like a student who got a "C" on the first half of their report card but has been getting "A"s lately. They are much better than they looked in April and May, but they still aren’t quite ready for the "final exam" (the playoffs) without a little extra help.
That is why General Manager A.J. Preller—the guy in charge of building the team—will be working the phones right up until Monday’s 3 p.m. trade deadline. His goal? Plug the remaining holes so the team can make a serious run in October.
IMPORTANT POINT
The Trade Deadline is the last day during the season when teams can trade players with each other. After this date, rosters are mostly locked in for the playoffs.
Who is A.J. Preller? (The "Trade Wizard")
If there were a trophy for "Winning the Trade Deadline," Preller would need a glass case for his four championships. He is famous for making big, surprising moves in July.
- Unpredictable: Nobody can confidently guess what he will do.
- Aggressive: He "makes things happen" when other teams are just waiting.
- Recent History: In 2022, he got superstar Juan Soto and closer Josh Hader. Last year, he made five trades in one day, adding six players without spending an extra dime.
This year? Experts don’t think a massive "blockbuster" (trading for a superstar) is coming. The plan is simpler: add a solid starting pitcher and a left-handed hitter.
The Money Situation
Preller has permission to add salary (payroll), but his "wallet" isn’t bottomless. He has some spending money, but not enough to just buy whoever he wants. He has to be smart and creative.
The Big Dilemma: To Trade Mason Miller or Adrián Morejón?
The Padres have a superpower: their bullpen (relief pitchers). It is deep, scary good, and the envy of the league. But to get new players, other teams want your best pitchers. Here are the two big names being discussed:
1. Mason Miller (The "Untouchable" Closer)
- Who he is: A "generational talent" — arguably one of the best closers in baseball right now.
- Contract: The Padres control his rights for three more years after this one (very valuable).
- Status: Almost certainly staying. The team is playing well (only 1 game out of a playoff spot), and trading him would signal "giving up."
2. Adrián Morejón (The Trade Candidate)
- Who he is: A left-handed reliever having an elite three-year run. He is 27 and becoming a free agent this winter (he can sign with any team).
- Value: Other teams would pay a high price for him because top relievers are rare.
- The Risk: Trading him creates a massive hole in that superpower bullpen. Preller’s philosophy has always been: you can never have too many great relievers. He added Hader, Scott, Adam, and Miller on top of already having a closer.
KEY TAKEAWAY
Preller builds playoff teams on deep, back-loaded bullpens. Trading away a key piece of that foundation (like Morejón) to fix other holes is risky—it might be "robbing Peter to pay Paul."
Trading from Strength: The "Major League" Market
Because the Padres’ farm system (minor league prospects) is ranked near the bottom of the league (~#30), they don’t have a treasure chest of future stars to trade away like they did in 2020 (when they traded 16 players!).
The Solution: Trade current Major League players—specifically from that stacked bullpen.
- They have four left-handed relievers. Other teams desperately want lefty relievers.
- Trading one allows them to get a starter or hitter without emptying the farm system.
The Prospect Cupboard: Not Empty, Just Different
- Ranking: Outsiders rank the farm system ~#30, but insiders think it’s better (maybe #15-#20).
- Currency: They have enough "mid-level" prospects to package together for good players.
- The "Untouchable": Catcher Ethan Salas (a top-tier teen prospect) is not expected to be moved.
- Recent Blueprint: Last July, they traded six 2024 draft picks (basically lottery tickets) for veterans Ramón Laureano and Ryan O’Hearn. They could do something similar again.
The Shopping List: Who Might the Padres Target?
Disclaimer: The Padres have "kicked the tires" (shown interest) on almost everyone available. This list is incomplete but covers the big names linked to them recently.
Starting Pitchers (The "Innings Eaters")
The Padres need a "middle-of-the-rotation" guy—someone reliable who pitches 5-6 innings every 5th day.
| Pitcher | Team | Key Stats / Cost | Why He Fits |
|---|---|---|---|
| Freddy Peralta | Mets | 4.99 ERA; $2.4M owed | Known for eating innings; Padres have scouted Mets heavily. |
| Clay Holmes | Mets | Returning from broken leg; $3.8M owed | Former All-Star closer converted to starter; high upside if healthy. |
| Reid Detmers | Angels | 4.03 ERA; $800k owed (controlled thru 2028) | Cheap & controllable. High competition from other teams. |
| José Soriano | Angels | 3.29 ERA; $800k owed (controlled thru 2028) | Same as Detmers: cheap, young, controlled. Very popular target. |
| Casey Mize | Tigers | 2.70 ERA; $1.6M owed | Former #1 overall pick breaking out. Price in prospects will be steep. |
| Ryan Weathers | Yankees | 3.99 ERA; Cheap/Controlled | Ex-Padre! Traded away in 2023. Padres know him well. |
| Will Warren | Yankees | 4.14 ERA; Cheap/Controlled | Young Yankee starter; NY needs bullpen help (Padres have extra). |
| Emerson Hancock | Mariners | 3.26 ERA; $200k owed (controlled thru 2030) | Incredible contract value. Seattle likely asks for a king’s ransom. |
| George Kirby | Mariners | 3.98 ERA; $2.2M owed (controlled thru 2029) | Ace-caliber talent. Almost certainly too expensive. |
| Nick Lodolo | Reds | 4.60 ERA (but 2.01 vs SD); $1.4M owed | Kryptonite vs Padres. Left-handed. Controlled one more year. |
| Robbie Ray | Giants | 3.08 ERA; $7.4M owed | Expensive. Giants might pay part of salary if Padres send better prospects. |
Left-Handed Hitters (The "Lineup Balancers")
The lineup is very right-handed heavy. They need a lefty bat.
| Hitter | Team | Key Stats / Cost | The Catch |
|---|---|---|---|
| Luis Arraez | Padres? | .328 AVG (MLB Leader); $3.5M owed | He only plays 2B. Padres already have too many second basemen. |
| Mickey Moniak | Rockies | .881 OPS, 17 HR; $1.7M owed (thru 2027) | Perfect fit: Lefty, power, local kid (San Diego HS). Every team wants him. |
| Jarren Duran | Red Sox | .589 OPS (Struggling) | Preller has loved him for years. Buying low on a down year? Risky. |
| JJ Bleday | Reds | .813 OPS, 19 HR; $400k owed (thru 2028) | Cheap, controlled, mashes lefties. Has owned the Padres historically (6-for-23, 2 HR). |
The "Secret Weapon": Internal Reinforcements
Here is the argument for not making a huge trade: The cavalry is coming home.
Manager Craig Stammen said: "The 26 guys we’ve got right here are exactly who I need and who we need to win it all."
Look at the evidence since June 30th:
- Offense Exploded: 5.11 runs/game (7th in MLB); .788 OPS (4th in MLB).
- Creative Pitching: Using a "dual starter" + 11-man bullpen strategy to keep arms fresh.
- Reinforcements Arriving:
- Jeremiah Estrada (elite reliever) → Back from Injury.
- Jason Adam (All-Star reliever) → Expected back soon.
- Joe Musgrove (Veteran Starter) → Expected back this month.
- Nick Pivetta (Veteran Starter) → Expected back this month.
If Musgrove and Pivetta give them quality starts, the rotation suddenly looks playoff-ready without a trade.
Summary: What Will Happen Monday?
- Expect a Move: Preller almost always makes some deal.
- Likely Targets: A mid-rotation starter (maybe Detmers, Soriano, Weathers, or Lodolo) + a lefty bat (Moniak or Bleday fit best).
- The Cost: Probably a mix of Major League relievers (maybe one of the 4 lefties) + mid-tier prospects.
- The "Big Names" Stay: Mason Miller stays. Ethan Salas stays. Adrián Morejón might go (it’s the biggest debate).
- The Real Key: Getting Musgrove and Pivetta healthy might matter more than any trade.
FAQ: Your Trade Deadline Questions Answered
1. What exactly is the "Trade Deadline"?
It is the last date (July 31st usually, August 2nd this year) during the regular season when teams can swap players. After 3 p.m. ET on Monday, rosters are frozen for the playoff push.
2. Why would the Padres trade a good reliever like Adrián Morejón?
Currency. They lack top-tier prospects (minor leaguers) to trade for a starter. Other teams really want good relievers. Trading from a position of strength (8-9 great relievers) to fix a weakness (rotation/lineup) is a calculated gamble.
3. Who is Ethan Salas and why is he "untouchable"?
He is a 19-year-old catcher considered one of the best hitting prospects in baseball. Catchers who hit like him are unicorns. The Padres view him as a future franchise cornerstone for the next decade.
4. What does "team control" mean?
It means how many more years the team owns the player’s rights before they become a free agent.
- More Control (e.g., 2028) = High Trade Value. The trading team gets the player for cheap for several years.
- Less Control (e.g., Free Agent this winter) = Lower Value. The player is just a "rental" for two months.
5. If the offense is 4th in MLB since June 30th, why do they need a hitter?
Balance. The lineup is very right-handed heavy. Good playoff teams have left-handed pitchers who dominate right-handed batters. Adding a quality lefty bat (like Moniak or Bleday) forces the opponent to make tough decisions late in games.
