The Mets’ Rough Season: Lessons from Other Teams, Young Players, and a "Miracle" Math Problem

The Big Picture: Can a Terrible Season Turn Into a Championship?

Imagine your baseball team is having a really, really bad year. They’re losing way more than they’re winning. Fans are frustrated. Everyone is asking: "Is this it? Are we stuck being bad forever?"

Good news: History says no. Two star players on the New York Mets—Marcus Semien and Bo Bichette—have seen this exact movie before. They know the ending can be a happy one.

IMPORTANT POINT
A bad season does not mean a bad future. Both Semien and Bichette played on teams that lost a lot of games one year, then won a championship (or came very close) the very next year.

Section 1: The "Been There, Done That" Club

Marcus Semien’s Story (Texas Rangers)

2022 (Year 1): The Rangers lost 94 games. That’s really bad.
2023 (Year 2): They won the World Series (the championship!).
What changed? The team signed two ace pitchers (Jacob deGrom and Nathan Eovaldi) and their offense clicked.

Bo Bichette’s Story (Toronto Blue Jays)

2024: Bichette got hurt, the team struggled, and they finished last place with 88 losses.
2025: They came within two outs of winning the championship.
What changed? The team committed to their core players (like extending Vladimir Guerrero Jr.’s contract) and simplified everything. As Bichette said: "We just showed up every day wanting to win."

What This Means for the 2025 Mets

Current record: 50 wins, 66 losses (as of the article date).
Semien says it feels like his first year in Texas: "Guys trying to get comfortable to a new place… a lot of new faces."
Bichette’s advice: Look in the mirror. Focus less on individual stats, more on what kind of team you want to be. The answer should be: A winning team.

Section 2: How to Turn "Losing" into "Motivation"

Both players agree: Pride is a powerful fuel.

Player	Key Takeaway
Bo Bichette	"If you have any pride in yourself, you should be motivated after not accomplishing your goals. I want to be known as a winner."
Marcus Semien	Finish the season strong. Even if the team stinks, you play well at the end. Then work on your weaknesses in the offseason. Build momentum for next year.
Both	Don’t wait until next spring. Bichette: "I don’t think there’s any reason we can’t start (getting better) right now."

Section 3: The Center Field Puzzle (A.J. Ewing vs. Luis Robert Jr.)

The Situation

A.J. Ewing = The Mets’ center fielder of the future.
Luis Robert Jr. = A really good center fielder they kept at the trade deadline.
Problem: Robert has never played left field in his entire pro career (595 games, all in center).

The Plan (Step-by-Step)

Give Robert practice reps in left field. He needs to get comfortable reading balls off the bat from a different angle.
Once Robert is ready in left, Ewing gets more reps in center.
Keep Carson Benge in right field. He’s emerging as a keeper there.

The Money Question

The Mets have a $20 million option on Robert for 2027 (or a $2 million buyout).
With Ewing and Benge playing well, it’s hard to see them paying $20M for Robert to be a backup/part-timer.

Section 4: Protecting the Young Arms (Innings Limits)

Young pitchers who had Tommy John surgery (elbow ligament replacement) are on strict "pitch counts" for their long-term health.

Christian Scott

Status: NOT shutting down yet (as of article date).
Innings so far: 74⅓ in MLB (88 total including minors).
Milestone: His next start will set a career high for innings in a season.
Plan: Week-to-week. The team checks how he feels after every single game. If the body says "stop," they stop. Right now, the body says "go."

Other Young Starters to Watch

Zac Thornton: Already threw more innings than ever before in his career.
Nolan McLean: About 30 innings away from his career high (set in 2025).

Section 5: Kodai Senga — The Reliever Experiment

The Backstory

Senga signed to be a starting pitcher.
As a starter recently: 0-7 record, 9.66 ERA (very bad). Since returning from injury last July: 7.57 ERA in 17 starts.
Contract: Owed $15 million in 2027 (final year).

The Pivot: Move to the Bullpen

Early results: Good! Scoreless 9th inning Tuesday. 1-2-3 7th inning with 2 strikeouts Thursday.
The Recipe for Success: Throw hard (high-90s fastball) + Throw the Forkball (his signature pitch). That’s it. Simplify.
Senga’s Attitude: He wants to start. But he accepts the team’s decision: "Whatever role is given to me, I’m going to continue to perform… and have a long career."
Team’s Hope: If he dominates late in games, they get value from that $15M salary.

Section 6: Who is Gabe Davis? (The New Guy)

The Mets got right-handed pitcher Gabe Davis from the White Sox in the Huascar Brazobán trade.

The Scout’s Report (Trey Cobb, former Mets scout, now at Oklahoma State)

IMPORTANT POINT
"They’re getting an elite body… an underrated elite athlete. I don’t know how many sports he played in high school — I think all of them."

Why Cobb is Excited (The "Projectability")

Size + Athleticism = Rare. 6-foot-9 pitchers usually struggle to repeat their delivery (throw the ball the same way every time). Davis moves like an athlete, so he can repeat it.
Starter Potential. He was a reliever in college (shorter season), but Cobb thinks he has the arsenal (pitch mix) and aptitude (smarts) to start.
The Key: Narrow the arsenal. In pro ball, you don’t need 6 pitches; you need 3 great ones. "Once he masters the arsenal, this guy’s going to dominate."
Track Record: Dominated High-A (2.63 ERA), struggled in Double-A (8.31 ERA). That’s normal for a young pitcher adjusting.

Next Step

Debut: Saturday for Binghamton (Double-A).

Section 7: The "Miracle" Math: What Would It Take to Make the Playoffs?

Let’s play a fun numbers game. The Mets swept Cleveland! Can they actually make the playoffs?

The Target

Wild Card spots: Held by Phillies (projected 87 wins) and Diamondbacks (projected 84 wins).
Tiebreaker: D-backs own it. Mets need 85 wins to pass Arizona.
Current Record: 50-66 (34 games left).
Required Finish: 35-10 (wait, article says 38-11 in final 49? Let’s check the math… Article says "starting with the trade deadline" needing 38-11 in final 49. Current record 50-66 implies 46 games left? Let’s stick to the article’s specific scenario: 38-11 in final 49 games to reach 85-77).

Has Anyone Done This Before?

YES. The 1969 "Miracle Mets" went 38-11 in their final 49 games.

Other Teams With Similar Hot Streaks (38+ wins in last 49)

2017 Cleveland (Francisco Lindor): 41-8
2001 Oakland A’s
2002 Oakland A’s
2021 Los Angeles Dodgers

The Catch

Every single one of those teams was ABOVE .500 when the streak started.
The 1978 Pirates were 10 games UNDER .500 (like these Mets) and went 37-12. They missed the playoffs… BUT… that surge built the foundation for a Championship the very next year (1979).

IMPORTANT POINT
Even if the "Miracle" falls short this year, playing winning baseball now builds the culture for a championship next year. Just ask the 1979 Pirates. Or Marcus Semien. Or Bo Bichette.

Summary: The State of the Mets

The Vibe: Veterans Semien & Bichette say "We’ve seen this. It turns around fast if you commit to winning now."
The Defense: Ewing is the future in CF. Robert is learning LF to make room. Benge locks down RF.
The Pitching (Health First): Scott stays on the mound (week-to-week). Thornton & McLean setting career highs. Senga finds life (and value) in the bullpen.
The Lottery Ticket: Gabe Davis (6’9", athletic, high ceiling) starts in Double-A Saturday.
The Scoreboard: Playoffs are a mathematical longshot (38-11 needed). But winning the last 2 months is the real goal—it builds the 2026 contender.

FAQ: Your Burning Questions Answered

1. Are the Mets actually going to make the playoffs this year?

Honestly? Almost certainly not. The math (needing to go 38-11) is historically difficult, and every other team that did it started the streak with a winning record. The Mets are 16 games under .500. Enjoy the wins, but don’t book October travel.

2. Why move Kodai Senga to the bullpen if he wants to start?

Because his starting stats are terrible (7.57 ERA since last July). In the ‘pen, he only needs two pitches (fastball/forkball) for one inning. It simplifies his job, maximizes his best stuff, and helps the team now. Plus, it might save his career/value for 2027.

3. Is Luis Robert Jr. going to be a Met next year?

Probably not. He’s a center fielder. The Mets have a better/cheaper one in A.J. Ewing. Robert has never played left. The Mets have a $20M option for 2027—they’ll almost certainly pay the $2M buyout and let him go free agency.

4. What is "Tommy John Surgery" and why does it limit Christian Scott’s innings?

It’s reconstruction of the ulnar collateral ligament (UCL) in the elbow using a tendon from elsewhere in the body. Recovery takes 12-18 months. After returning, teams strictly limit innings jumps (usually +30-40 innings max per year) to protect the new ligament. Scott is hitting his limit right now.

5. Who is Gabe Davis and why should I care?

He’s a 6-foot-9, multi-sport athlete pitcher acquired for a reliever (Brazobán). He’s a high-risk, high-reward "project." If he learns to command 3 pitches consistently, he could be a frontline starter. If not, he’s just a tall guy who throws hard. He debuts Saturday—keep an eye on the Binghamton box score!

Go Mets. Build the culture. Win the future.

Popular Posts