Murdaugh Retrial Hearing Friday: Venue, Evidence & How to Watch Live
Alex Murdaugh Back in Court: What You Need to Know About the Possible Retrial
Quick Update: Former attorney Alex Murdaugh appears in court Friday at 10 a.m. in Lexington County, South Carolina. This hearing will help decide what happens next in his murder case.
The Big Picture in Simple Terms
Imagine a very famous court case got a "do-over." That’s basically what’s happening here. Alex Murdaugh was found guilty of murdering his wife and son, but the highest court in South Carolina said, "Wait — there were mistakes. Let’s try this again." Now, everyone is figuring out how, when, and where that second trial will happen.
How We Got Here: A Timeline
- June 2021 — Murdaugh’s wife Maggie and son Paul are killed.
- 2023 — Murdaugh goes on trial and is convicted of murder.
- 2024 — Murdaugh pleads guilty to federal financial crimes and gets a 40-year federal prison sentence (this sentence stands no matter what happens with the murder case).
- May 2026 — The South Carolina Supreme Court overturns the murder conviction and orders a new trial.
- June 2026 — Judge Debra McCaslin sets a tentative retrial date: April 2027.
- August 2026 — Judge McCaslin rules Murdaugh can wear civilian clothes and be unshackled in court.
- Friday, August 2026 — Today’s hearing to sort out key details before the retrial.
What’s Different This Time? Murdaugh Will Be Unshackled
Important Point: The judge ruled that Murdaugh can wear regular clothes (not a jail jumpsuit) and won’t be handcuffed or shackled during hearings.
Why?
In America, you are presumed innocent until proven guilty. Since the conviction was wiped out, Murdaugh is legally innocent right now. The judge wants the jury (when one is picked) to see him as a regular person — not a prisoner.
Where Will the Retrial Happen? The Big Fight
The first trial was in Colleton County — a small, rural area where the Murdaugh family was very powerful and well-known. Now, both sides are arguing over where the second trial should be.
The Defense Wants: Charleston County
- Bigger city = bigger jury pool
- Jurors less likely to know the Murdaugh family personally
- Better chance for a fair trial
The Prosecution (State) Says: Not Charleston
- Too expensive and complicated logistically
- The tentative trial date (April 2027) overlaps with The Masters golf tournament → hotels and costs skyrocket
- Alternative counties proposed by the state:
Spartanburg
Florence
York
Newberry
Lancaster
Did You Know? The defense pointed to a recent civil case (about a 2019 boat crash that killed Mallory Beach) where a judge moved the trial out of Hampton County — part of the same judicial circuit as Colleton — because a fair trial wasn’t possible there. They’re using that as proof their request makes sense.
The Evidence Battle: What Can Be Used?
1. Murdaugh’s 2023 Testimony
- Defense says: Don’t allow it.
Murdaugh only took the stand because the prosecution showed financial crime evidence that the Supreme Court later said should never have been allowed. Using his testimony now violates his Fifth Amendment right against self-incrimination. - State says: We should be able to use it.
2. Phone Evidence from 2021
- State wants: Digital data extracted from Murdaugh’s phone back in 2021.
- Defense says: You already have this.
3. Evidence Sharing
- State asks: Defense must hand over all physical evidence they plan to use.
4. Motion to Drop the Indictments
- Defense argues: The murder charges should be thrown out completely because former SLED agent David Owen gave inaccurate testimony to the grand jury that led to the indictment.
Can You Watch the Hearing?
YES!
WIS will livestream the entire hearing starting at 10 a.m. Friday.
You can watch it on their website, app, or streaming platforms.
ELI5 Summary: What Just Happened?
| Question | Simple Answer |
|---|---|
| Who is Alex Murdaugh? | A former lawyer from a powerful SC family, accused of killing his wife and son. |
| Was he found guilty? | Yes, in 2023 — but the state Supreme Court threw that out in 2026. |
| Is he in prison now? | Yes — 40 years for financial crimes (he admitted guilt). That sentence stays. |
| What’s happening Friday? | A hearing to decide where the new trial will be, what evidence can be used, and other ground rules. |
| Will he wear an orange jumpsuit? | No. He’ll wear regular clothes and no handcuffs — because he’s legally innocent right now. |
| When is the new trial? | Tentatively April 2027 — but location still undecided. |
FAQ: Your Top Questions Answered
1. If Murdaugh is already in federal prison, why does this murder trial matter?
Because the murder charges are separate from the financial crimes. If he’s convicted again, he could face life in state prison without parole — on top of his federal time. It also brings legal closure for the victims’ families.
2. Why did the Supreme Court overturn the first conviction?
The court ruled that financial crime evidence (like stealing millions from clients) was wrongly allowed in the murder trial. That evidence made Murdaugh look bad but wasn’t directly related to the murders — and it likely pushed him to testify in his own defense, which the court said was unfair.
3. What does "presumption of innocence" mean?
It means the law treats you as innocent until a jury says otherwise. Since the first conviction was erased, Murdaugh is legally innocent right now — so he gets to look like a regular person in court, not a prisoner.
4. Why does the trial location matter so much?
In small towns, everyone knows everyone. The Murdaugh family dominated the Lowcountry for generations. A fair jury = people who don’t already have opinions about the family. That’s harder in Colleton County.
5. Can the murder charges really be dropped before the retrial?
It’s possible but rare. The defense claims the grand jury was misled by a key witness (David Owen). If the judge agrees the indictment was based on false testimony, the charges could be dismissed — but prosecutors could likely re-indict him.
Final Takeaways
- Murdaugh is back in court Friday — not for trial, but for a pre-trial hearing.
- He’s legally innocent right now — conviction overturned, retrial pending.
- He’s still in federal prison for 40 years on financial crimes.
- Big fights ahead: Where to hold the trial? What evidence is allowed? Can his past testimony be used?
- You can watch it live at 10 a.m. on WIS.
Stay informed. Stay curious.
This case is far from over — and every hearing shapes what justice looks like in one of America’s most-watched legal sagas.
Copyright 2026 WIS. All rights reserved.