Carnegie Deli Returns to 7th Ave With Legendary Pastrami & Bagels
Carnegie Deli Is Coming Back to New York City!
The Big News
After nearly 10 years away, one of New York City’s most famous delis is reopening its doors! Carnegie Deli — the legendary spot known for massive sandwiches and celebrity sightings — will be back in business in mid-September 2024.
New Location: 834 Seventh Avenue (just down the block from the old spot at 854 Seventh Avenue)
Seating: 110 seats
Walk-ins only — no reservations!
A Quick History Lesson (ELI5 Style)
Imagine a restaurant that opened before your grandparents were born — that’s Carnegie Deli!
| Year | What Happened |
|---|---|
| 1937 | Carnegie Deli opens near Carnegie Hall |
| 2015 | Temporary closure due to a gas pipe investigation |
| Dec 31, 2016 | Closes for good (or so we thought!) |
| 2017–2024 | Brand lives on at events, pop-ups, and online |
| Mid-Sept 2024 | Grand reopening! |
Who’s Running the Show?
Sarri Harper — the third-generation owner — is at the helm. She’s keeping it in the family and bringing back all the classic recipes that made the deli famous.
What’s on the Menu?
Get ready for some serious comfort food:
- Corned beef & pastrami on rye (piled high!)
- Fresh bagels
- Latkes (potato pancakes)
- Knishes (stuffed dough pockets)
- Chopped liver
- Smoked fish
- "Legendary oversized New York cheesecake" — yes, it’s that big!
Important Note: While it’s a Jewish-style deli rooted in tradition and New York pride, the restaurant is not kosher.
What Will the New Deli Look Like?
They’re carefully restoring the original Carnegie Deli experience:
- Famous illuminated sign — you can’t miss it!
- Wood-paneled walls — cozy, classic vibes
- Iconic Wall of Fame — covered in celebrity photographs
- Closely set tables — that intimate, bustling energy
- Full waiter service — just like the old days
Fun Fact: It’s a Movie Star!
Carnegie Deli played a starring role in Woody Allen’s film "Broadway Danny Rose."
Scenes filmed at the deli open and close the movie, giving it that authentic, nostalgic New York feel.
Famous Faces Who Hung Out Here
Back in the day, comedians like Henny Youngman and tons of other big names made this their go-to spot. The Wall of Fame has the photos to prove it!
The Brand Never Really Left
Even while the physical restaurant was closed, Carnegie Deli stayed alive at:
- U.S. Open
- Madison Square Garden
- Saratoga Race Course
- Online ordering
- Pop-ups (including one in SoHo for The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel on Amazon Prime!)
A Little Drama in 2015
The year before closing, the deli made headlines when Con Edison accused them of using a hidden pipe to misappropriate natural gas for six years. The New York Times reported on it, and the deli temporarily shut down during the investigation.
Summary
| What | Details |
|---|---|
| What’s happening? | Carnegie Deli is reopening! |
| When? | Mid-September 2024 |
| Where? | 834 Seventh Ave (near Carnegie Hall) |
| Who’s in charge? | Sarri Harper, 3rd-gen owner |
| Seating? | 110 seats, walk-in only |
| Vibe? | Restored original — sign, wood panels, Wall of Fame |
| Menu? | All the classics: huge sandwiches, latkes, knishes, massive cheesecake |
| Kosher? | No, but Jewish-style & proud of it |
FAQ
Is this the exact same Carnegie Deli from 1937?
Yes and no. It’s the same family ownership (third generation!), same recipes, same location area, and they’re restoring the original look and feel. But it’s a new physical space at 834 Seventh Ave instead of 854.
Do I need a reservation?
Nope! It’s walk-in only — just like the old days. Get there early if you want a seat during peak hours.
Is the food kosher?
No. The deli is Jewish-style and rooted in Jewish deli tradition, but it is not certified kosher.
Will the cheesecake really be "oversized"?
Absolutely. The "legendary oversized New York cheesecake" is one of their signature items — bring a friend (or three) to share a slice!
Can I still get Carnegie Deli food at the U.S. Open or MSG?
Yes! The brand has continued selling at those venues even during the closure. But now you can visit the actual restaurant again.
Bottom line: A true NYC institution is back. Whether you’re a longtime fan who misses the pastrami or a newbie ready for your first mile-high sandwich — Carnegie Deli is returning to serve up a slice of New York history.