Faisal Khan, popularly known as Khan Sir, is a Patna-based educator and YouTuber renowned for his engaging teaching style and a vast following among aspirants for government exams. Despite his success, a resurfaced video from five years ago has landed him in controversy. In the clip, Khan Sir provides an explanation of the roles of Cabinet Ministers, Ministers of State, and Ministers of State with Independent Charge that many have labeled erroneous. Critics accuse him of spreading misinformation and question the credibility of his rapid rise to fame during the COVID-19 pandemic. The controversy has reignited debates about the quality of content delivered by popular educators online.
Khan Sir’s old video goes viral: Koi Bhi Bacha Yeh Video Dekh Kar Aapko Burbak Keh Dega
The controversial video, uploaded on Khan Sir’s YouTube channel Khan GS Research Centre, showcases his attempt to differentiate between the ministerial roles. He stated, “A Minister of State cannot make independent decisions. However, if the Cabinet Minister is unavailable, the Minister of State temporarily assumes responsibility for the department. During this period, they act as the head and are referred to as having Independent Charge.”
YouTuber Faisal Khan added, “While holding Independent Charge, the Minister of State can operate autonomously, but once the Cabinet Minister returns, the designation reverts to Minister of State. At any given time, the role can only be one of the two—either Minister of State or Minister of State with Independent Charge. When the Cabinet Minister is present, it’s the former; when absent, it becomes the latter.”
This explanation sparked backlash, with critics calling it misleading and an oversimplification of the actual roles.
Khan Sir’s old viral video | Watch here:
Reactions on social media
The video went viral, prompting heated discussions online. A user on X (formerly Twitter) commented, “Your name is Khan Sir, and some even call you a map expert. From teaching railway gatekeeper courses to ambassadorial coaching, your branding during the pandemic made you a nationwide sensation.”
The same user further criticised, “You once claimed to have received a Rs 107-crore offer, yet your explanation of ministerial roles is laughable. Any serious government exam aspirant would dismiss this as unworthy of serious consideration.”
These critiques were part of a larger conversation about the responsibility of educators with massive platforms to ensure accuracy in their content, particularly when preparing students for competitive exams.
Where did Khan Sir go wrong?
The roles of Cabinet Ministers, Ministers of State, and Ministers of State with Independent Charge have distinct functions:
- Ministers of State assist Cabinet Ministers and often work under their supervision. While they may have defined responsibilities, significant policy decisions typically require Cabinet approval.
- Ministers of State with Independent Charge, on the other hand, manage their departments autonomously without the oversight of a Cabinet Minister, making them similar to Cabinet Ministers within limited scopes.
Khan Sir’s explanation conflated these roles, leading to confusion among his viewers.
Who is Khan Sir?
Faisal Khan, better known as Khan Sir, is an educator who has built a massive following for his dynamic and relatable teaching methods. His YouTube channel boasts over 21.3 million subscribers, making him one of the most influential educators on the platform.
However, his journey has not been without obstacles:
- Challenges in establishing his institute: After gaining initial popularity, Khan Sir faced attempts to forcibly take over his coaching center. Disheartened, he started anew with support from former students.
- Attacks on his coaching center: His affordable fees for UPSC aspirants angered competitors, leading to attacks, including the use of bombs, at his premises.
Despite these hurdles, Khan Sir leveraged online platforms during the COVID-19 pandemic, gaining widespread recognition. His estimated monthly income from YouTube is Rs 10–12 lakh, with a reported net worth of around Rs 5 crore.
The larger debate
This controversy raises broader questions about the accountability of educators in the digital age. With millions relying on platforms like Khan Sir’s for guidance, the accuracy and integrity of educational content are paramount. It also underscores the importance of critical thinking among students, encouraging them to verify information rather than accept it at face value.
Also read | Airtel recharge plans | Jio recharge plans | BSNL recharge plans
#YouTuber #Khan #Sir #giving #wrong #information #Cabinet #State #ministers #video #viral #Times #India
