11
Florida Set for Rare Same-Day Double Execution
Florida Plans Two Executions in One Day for First Time in 60 Years
Important Callout: Florida is scheduled to execute two men on the same day — a rare event that hasn’t happened in the state since 1964. This comes as Florida has dramatically increased its pace of executions under Governor Ron DeSantis.
What’s Happening?
On Tuesday, the state of Florida plans to put two death row inmates to death just six hours apart. This would be:
- The first time in over 60 years Florida has executed multiple people in a single day
- Only the third time in 26 years any U.S. state has done this (Arkansas in 2017, Texas in 2000)
- Both executions will use lethal injection
Who Are the Two Men?
James Duckett
- Age: Not specified (but has spent 30+ years on death row)
- Background: Former police officer in Mascotte, Florida
- Crime: Convicted of murdering 11-year-old Teresa McAbee in 1987
- Key details:
- Last person seen with Teresa
- Her body was found in a lake — she had been sexually assaulted, strangled, and drowned
- Fingerprints and tire tracks linked him to the crime
- Maintains his innocence — recent DNA testing was inconclusive
- Scheduled for noon execution
Dominick Occhicone
- Age: 80 years old
- Crime: Convicted of killing his ex-girlfriend’s parents, Raymond and Martha Artzner, in 1986
- Key details:
- Cut phone lines, then fatally shot both victims
- Would be the second person in their 80s ever executed in modern U.S. history
- Argued execution violates Eighth Amendment (cruel/unusual punishment) due to age/health — rejected by Florida Supreme Court
- Scheduled for evening execution (hours after Duckett)
Why Is This a Big Deal?
Florida’s Execution Surge
| Year | Florida Executions | National Context |
|---|---|---|
| 2025 | 19 (record high — more than double previous record) | 47 total nationwide — Florida did 40% of all executions |
| 2026 (so far) | 10 already | More than half of all U.S. executions this year |
Major Concerns from Advocates
-
Florida leads the nation in death row exonerations
- 30 people freed since 1973 after being wrongly convicted
- Risk of executing innocent people increases with speed
-
Rushed process = more mistakes?
- "Botched executions" more likely when staff are overworked
- Two executions in one day strains the system
- Governor has too much power
- Florida is one of few states where the governor alone signs death warrants
- No judge or jury involved in setting execution dates
- Critics call it "secretive" and "ripe for abuse"
The Political Context
Governor Ron DeSantis
- Says death penalty is "appropriate punishment for the worst offenders" and a "strong deterrent"
- Claims he’s delivering justice for victims’ families: "Justice delayed is justice denied"
- Critics (including ACLU) say he’s using executions to boost his political future
- Pace accelerated after Trump called for expanding the death penalty nationally
What DeSantis Said About the Delay
"We had to get our sea legs… Covid impacted corrections… I felt I was letting victims’ families down."
Voices From Inside
Father Dustin Feddon (Catholic priest, 10+ years visiting death row)
- Will be with Duckett in the death chamber
- Describes the two executions as a "rupture to the system"
- Calls executing 80-year-olds "unconscionable" and "even more cruel and unusual"
- Questions: "Why are we as a state still choosing to answer violence by killing people?"
Maya Foa (CEO of Reprieve, anti-death penalty org)
"This is an execution spree at a grand scale… asking for more problems."
Maria DeLiberato (ACLU Capital Punishment Project)
"This administration is the most active death penalty administration we’ve ever seen."
Legal Challenges Still Pending
Both men have filed lawsuits to stop their executions:
- Duckett’s team: Claims state chose a lab that couldn’t do proper DNA testing — wants more time to prove innocence
- Occhicone’s team: Argues age and health make execution unconstitutional
- Both: Warn compressed timeline increases risk of botched executions
As of publication: All appeals remain pending.
The Bigger Picture: Death Penalty in America
| Era | Trend |
|---|---|
| 1976 | Supreme Court reinstates death penalty |
| 1999 | Peak — nearly 100 executions nationwide |
| Since then | Steady decline — fewer states, fewer executions |
| 2024-2025 | Sharp increase — 47 executions in 2024 (nearly double 2023) |
| Now | Florida driving the surge — outpacing rest of country |
Summary
- Florida will execute two men Tuesday — first same-day double execution since 1964
- James Duckett (1987 murder of child, maintains innocence) at noon
- Dominick Occhicone (1986 double murder, age 80) hours later
- Florida executed 19 people in 2025 — a modern record — and 10 already in 2026
- Governor alone decides execution dates — critics say this lacks transparency
- Florida leads U.S. in death row exonerations (30 since 1973) — raising innocence concerns
- Legal challenges pending for both men
- Priest and advocates call the pace "unconscionable" and dangerous
FAQ
Why is executing two people in one day so rare?
It puts enormous strain on prison staff, medical teams, and the execution protocol. Only Arkansas (2017) and Texas (2000) have done it in the last 26 years. Florida hasn’t since 1964.
Can the governor really decide execution dates alone?
Yes. Florida is one of the few states where the governor has sole authority to sign death warrants. No judge or jury sets the date — it’s an executive decision.
What does "botched execution" mean?
When something goes wrong during lethal injection — like difficulty finding veins, wrong drug mix, or the inmate showing signs of pain/suffering. Rushed schedules increase this risk.
Has anyone been proven innocent after execution?
We can’t know for sure after someone is executed. But 30 people on Florida’s death row have been exonerated and freed since 1973 — the most of any state. This proves innocent people have been sentenced to death.
Why is Dominick Occhicone’s age (80) significant?
He would be only the second octogenarian executed in modern U.S. history. His lawyers argued executing a frail, elderly person violates the Constitution’s ban on "cruel and unusual punishment." The court disagreed.
Final Thought: This moment highlights a deep national divide — between those who see the death penalty as justice for victims, and those who see a system moving too fast, with too much power in one person’s hands, risking irreversible mistakes.
