11
UFL Verdict In: Birmingham Stallions’ Future Decided
Birmingham Stallions Ride Off Into the Sunset: UFL Team Leaves After Three Championships
The Big News in Simple Terms
Imagine your favorite sports team wins three championships in a row. You’d think they’d stay forever, right? Well, the Birmingham Stallions—the kings of spring football—are packing up and leaving town anyway.
After five seasons (the longest professional spring football run in Birmingham’s history), the United Football League (UFL) announced the team will cease operations in Birmingham. The reason? Their stadium is "too big."
Why Is a Winning Team Leaving?
The Stadium Size Problem
- Protective Stadium holds 47,000 seats
- The UFL’s average stadium size across eight cities: ~21,250 seats
- League co-owner Mike Repole (a billionaire who bought a majority stake last year) wants "smaller stadiums, packed houses, real energy"
- He argues a 47,000-seat stadium "swallows the crowd" even when attendance is good
Important Point: The Stallions did have good crowds! Ticket revenue grew from 2025 to 2026. Season tickets increased. They finished in the top half of league attendance. But the league says the visual of empty seats looks bad on TV.
The "Goldilocks" Stadium Search
Repole publicly hunted for alternatives:
- Hoover Metropolitan Stadium — blocked by SEC Baseball Tournament (turf recovery time)
- Ideal size per Repole: 12,000–15,000 seats ("The right size is better. Bigger isn’t always better.")
- Result: No viable spring dates found → Team leaves
The Stallions’ Trophy Case
| Season | League | Result |
|---|---|---|
| 2022 | USFL | Champions |
| 2023 | USFL | Champions |
| 2024 | UFL | Champions |
| 2025 | UFL | 4–6 (missed playoffs) |
- First three years: Dominant dynasty under coach Skip Holtz
- 2025: Fired Holtz → Hired A.J. McCarron (former Alabama QB, zero head coaching experience)
- Result: First losing season, first playoff miss
Who Paid for What? (The Money Side)
The Public Did the Heavy Lifting
- City, BJCC, Convention & Visitors Bureau covered 100% of stadium costs
- Stallions only paid: team operating expenses (same costs they’d have anywhere)
- County Commission Chair Jimmie Stephens: "We did everything asked of us."
The League’s Business Model vs. Reality
- UFL owners: Fox, ESPN, RedBird Capital, Dwayne "The Rock" Johnson, Dany Garcia, Mike Repole
- Their model: Small venues = TV-friendly "packed house" optics
- Birmingham’s model: Big venue + public support = sustainable growth
- Clash: League made decision before giving Birmingham a requested 3-year growth window
What Local Leaders Say
"It bothers me."
— Jimmie Stephens, Jefferson County Commission Chair"Birmingham has been home to the Stallions since 2022. We have been proud to see the team’s success… We wish the organization well."
— Mayor Randall Woodfin"The only thing you can say is the facility swallows the crowd that comes to a UFL game. Not a Birmingham UFL game, but a UFL game."
— Gene Hallman, Eventive (ticket sales)"Birmingham’s position as a leading sports destination remains unchanged."
— Dan Williams, Greater Birmingham CVB (city just named Top 50 Sports Business City)
What Happens Next for Birmingham Sports?
The city isn’t slowing down:
- Magic City Classic (annual HBCU showdown)
- SEC Baseball Tournament (stays at Hoover Met)
- NCAA Championships & Tournaments
- Youth Sports Events (national draws)
- Top 50 Sports Business City recognition (2024)
Summary: The Story in a Nutshell
| What Happened | Why It Matters |
|---|---|
| 3-time champs leave after 5 years | Winning ≠ staying in spring football |
| Stadium "too big" (47K vs 21K league avg) | League prioritizes TV optics over local success |
| Public paid stadium costs; team paid ops | City held up its end; league walked away |
| Attendance & revenue grew in 2026 | Performance didn’t save them—perception did |
| No viable smaller stadium found | Hoover Met blocked by baseball; no Plan B |
| Birmingham remains a sports hub | Other events & reputation untouched |
FAQ: Your Questions Answered
Could the Stallions come back someday?
Maybe—but not soon. The UFL would need to change its stadium-size philosophy, or a new league would need to form. Birmingham’s infrastructure and fan base are ready; the league model is the hurdle.
Did the coaching change to A.J. McCarron cause this?
No. The decision was driven by stadium economics and owner philosophy. The 4–6 record didn’t help, but attendance grew despite it.
Why didn’t they just tarp off the upper deck?
Good question! Many teams do this (e.g., NFL’shrinking’ stadiums visually). The article doesn’t say if this was offered/rejected—but Repole’s posts suggest he wanted a physically smaller building, not a cosmetic fix.
Who owns the UFL?
A star-studded group: Fox, ESPN, RedBird Capital, Dwayne "The Rock" Johnson, Dany Garcia, and Mike Repole (majority stake since 2024). Repole’s public complaints foreshadowed this move.
Was this a surprise?
Not entirely. Repole threatened to pull the team in 2025 if season tickets didn’t rise. They did rise. He still left—showing the stadium size issue was the real dealbreaker.
Final Thought
Three championships. Growing crowds. Public partnership. Zero cost for the stadium.
And it still wasn’t enough.
The Stallions’ exit is a case study in modern sports economics: where how it looks on TV can matter more than how it performs in the stands. Birmingham showed up. The league looked at the empty seats on camera—and walked away.
Birmingham sports fans: keep your jerseys. This city’s sports story is far from over.
