11
Florida Executes Ex-Cop for Girl’s Murder; Double Execution Day Begins
Florida Carries Out Rare Double Execution in Single Day
What Happened in Florida on Tuesday?
On Tuesday, the state of Florida did something that hasn’t happened in America since 2017 — they executed two different men on the same day.
Think of it like this: Usually, when a state carries out the death penalty, they do it one person at a time, with weeks or months in between. But on this Tuesday, Florida put one man to death in the early afternoon and had another scheduled for the evening.
Important: Both executions were carried out by lethal injection — a three-drug combination that puts the person to sleep, stops their muscles from moving, and then stops their heart.
Who Were the Two Men?
1. James Aren Duckett (Age 68)
- Executed at: 1:19 p.m.
- Background: Former police officer in a small central Florida city
- Crime: Convicted of raping and drowning an 11-year-old girl in 1987 — while he was on duty as a police officer
- Time on death row: Nearly 37 years
- Final appeals: His lawyers claimed he was innocent and argued that DNA testing was mishandled. The results came back inconclusive (meaning they didn’t prove he did it, but didn’t prove he didn’t either). Courts let the original jury verdict stand.
2. Dominick Anthony Occhicone (Age 80)
- Scheduled for: 6:00 p.m. (same day)
- Crime: Convicted of killing his ex-girlfriend’s parents in 1986
- Time on death row: Nearly 38 years
- Final appeals: His lawyers argued that his age-related health problems (kidney and prostate issues) would make the execution extremely painful — which they said counts as "cruel and unusual punishment" (banned by the Constitution).
- Historical note: If executed, he would become:
- The oldest person ever executed in Florida’s modern history
- The second-oldest in modern U.S. history (after Walter Moody Jr., age 83, executed in Alabama in 2018)
Why Is This Such a Big Deal?
It’s Extremely Rare
- Last time a state did two executions in one day: Arkansas, April 2017 (three hours apart)
- Last time Florida did it: May 12, 1964 — over 60 years ago!
- Nationwide in 2026 so far: Only 17 executions total — and Florida has done more than all other states combined
Governor DeSantis Has Sped Things Up Dramatically
| Time Period | Executions in Florida |
|---|---|
| First 6 years of DeSantis (2019–2024) | 9 total |
| 2025 alone | 19 (record for any FL governor since 1976) |
| 2026 so far | 11 (including Tuesday’s two) |
| Projected final 2 years | 31 total |
Important: Governor DeSantis leaves office in January 2027. Another execution is already scheduled for August 2026, which could make this year another record-breaker.
How Did We Get Two Executions in One Day?
It wasn’t originally planned this way. Here’s the timeline:
- February 2026: DeSantis signs death warrant for Duckett, sets execution for March 31
- Late March: Florida Supreme Court stops Duckett’s execution days before — orders new DNA testing on old evidence (technology didn’t exist at original trial)
- DNA results come back: Inconclusive — doesn’t clear him, doesn’t confirm guilt
- July 8: Florida Supreme Court lifts the stay — allows execution to proceed
- July 14: DeSantis signs new death warrant for Duckett and adds him to Occhicone’s already-scheduled July 28 execution date
What Are People Saying?
Governor DeSantis’s View
"Some of these crimes were committed in the ’80s. Justice delayed is justice denied. I felt I owed it to [victims’ families] to make sure this ran very smoothly. If I honestly thought someone was innocent, I would not pull the trigger."
— Ron DeSantis, news conference (2025)
Death Penalty Opponents
Floridians for Alternatives to the Death Penalty called Tuesday:
"An unprecedented escalation of Florida’s use of the death penalty… These are two profoundly different cases, but they point to the same troubling reality: Florida continues to expand the use of capital punishment, despite mounting evidence that it is not what Floridians want."
— Grace Hanna, Executive Director
How Does Lethal Injection Work in Florida?
Florida uses a three-drug protocol (same method for both men):
| Drug # | Purpose | Simple Explanation |
|---|---|---|
| 1 | Sedative | Puts the person into a deep sleep (like anesthesia for surgery) |
| 2 | Paralytic | Stops all muscle movement (person can’t move or speak) |
| 3 | Heart-stopper | Stops the heart — causes death |
Note: Prison officials haven’t commented on whether doing two executions six hours apart created any logistical challenges.
Summary
- Florida executed two men on Tuesday — first time any state has done this since 2017
- James Duckett (68) died at 1:19 p.m. for a 1987 on-duty rape/murder of an 11-year-old
- Dominick Occhicone (80) was scheduled for 6 p.m. for a 1986 double murder
- Governor DeSantis has dramatically increased execution pace — 19 in 2025 (record), 11 so far in 2026
- Both men appealed to the U.S. Supreme Court — both were denied
- Occhicone would be oldest executed in FL history, 2nd oldest in modern US history
- Critics call it "unprecedented escalation"; DeSantis says it’s "justice for victims’ families"
FAQ
1. Why did Florida do two executions in one day?
The first execution (Duckett) was delayed for DNA testing. When the court allowed it to proceed in July, Governor DeSantis rescheduled it for the same day as Occhicone’s already-planned execution. It hadn’t been done in Florida in over 60 years.
2. What does "inconclusive DNA" mean?
It means the test results didn’t prove Duckett was innocent — but they also didn’t definitively link him to the crime. The courts decided the original jury’s guilty verdict should stand.
3. Is it legal to execute an 80-year-old with health problems?
Occhicone’s lawyers argued it would be "cruel and unusual punishment" (banned by the 8th Amendment). The courts disagreed and allowed the execution to proceed. The U.S. Supreme Court has previously ruled that age and illness alone don’t automatically stop an execution.
4. How many states still have the death penalty?
As of 2026, 27 states still have the death penalty on the books, but several have moratoriums (pauses) on actually carrying it out. Florida is currently the most active.
5. What happens next?
Another execution is scheduled for August 2026 in Florida. If carried out, 2026 could break 2025’s record. Governor DeSantis leaves office in January 2027, so this pace may not continue under the next governor.
