1
1
How a class-action lawsuit helped nearly half a million borrowers get their debt wiped clean
Imagine you bought a car that the dealer promised would last 10 years, get great gas mileage, and hold its value. But when you drove it off the lot, the engine fell out. You’d want your money back, right?
That’s basically what happened to hundreds of thousands of students. They borrowed money to attend colleges that made big promises about jobs, salaries, and transferable credits. Instead, many got:
Now, after a years-long legal battle, the government has agreed to a $23 billion settlement that will erase the federal student loans of about 450,000 borrowers.
| Administration | Case Name | What Happened |
|---|---|---|
| Trump (1st term) | Sweet v. DeVos | Lawsuit filed in 2019; government delayed processing claims |
| Biden | Sweet v. Cardona | Settlement reached but implementation dragged on |
| Trump (2nd term) | Sweet v. McMahon | Court forced action; 200,000 more borrowers approved |
The core issue: The Borrower Defense program exists to forgive loans when schools defraud students. But the Education Department sat on applications for years, leaving borrowers in limbo.
Important Point
"It makes clear that the federal government cannot simply disregard borrowers’ rights and its own legal obligations without consequence."
— Eileen Connor, President of The Project on Predatory Student Lending (the group that brought the lawsuit)
Dozens of schools were named in the settlement because the Department of Education found significant evidence of misconduct.
Key facts about these schools:
See the full list of schools here
The delay wasn’t just paperwork — it derailed lives:
One borrower’s story: Her debt ballooned from $250,000 to $400,000 just from interest while waiting for a decision.
Critical: You CANNOT newly apply today.
Eligibility is based on when you originally applied and which school you attended.
| Relief Type | Average Amount | Details |
|---|---|---|
| Loan Forgiveness | $48,000+ | Full balance cleared — individual amounts vary widely |
| Payment Refunds | $15,000+ | If you made payments on these loans, you may get that money back |
Pro Tip: Even if your loan balance was small, you could still get a refund for payments you already made!
Deadline: June 15, 2027 — that’s the absolute latest the Department can process your forgiveness.
Good news while you wait:
This settlement proves that when schools lie to students and the government drags its feet, the law can still win — even if it takes years.
No. The settlement only covers people who already had applications pending (as of Nov 2022) or were denied during a specific window (Dec 2019 – Oct 2020). You cannot newly qualify today.
For this specific settlement, yes. But you can still file a regular Borrower Defense claim if your school misled you. The process is just slower and not guaranteed.
No — it should help! Having a large debt erased improves your debt-to-income ratio. Forgiven loans typically show as "paid in full" or "discharged" on credit reports.
Not for federal student loans forgiven through Borrower Defense. Under current law (through 2025), discharged student loans aren’t taxable income. Always check with a tax pro for your specific situation.
This settlement doesn’t cover private loans. However, ~24 states have tuition recovery funds for students who attended for-profit schools that closed. Check with your state’s higher education agency!
Article based on CNBC reporting by Annie Nova. Original settlement details at StudentAid.gov.