1
1
Imagine the government keeps a big book of health info for people using a program called Medicaid (a kind of health help for people with low income). Some officials shared info from that book about millions of people with immigration officers (called ICE) when they weren’t supposed to. Then ICE gave that info to a tech company named Palantir. This all came out in new court papers.
Important Point: The data sharing was improper — it went beyond what a court said was allowed, and included people in the country legally and even U.S. citizens.
More than 20 Democratic state lawyers (attorneys general) filed a motion on Thursday. They had already sued the Trump administration last year because of a deal to share Medicaid data with ICE.
A judge named Vince Chhabria (in California, picked by President Obama) made some rules:
Federal officials admitted more wrong sharing recently:
Important Point: ICE was supposed to delete the bad data, but copies kept turning up — showing it’s tough to fully erase digital files.
Palantir got the Jan. 7 data from ICE. Court papers say it was shared over Microsoft Teams chat and deleted from there. A redacted transcript shows ICE asking Palantir to delete the file.
The Justice Department asks the judge to let ICE get data on more noncitizens — possibly all immigrants who are not permanent residents, citizens, or have permanent status.
The state lawyers wrote: "ICE’s inability to identify Medicaid records in its possession undercuts any claim that the agency should be entitled to more access." They said each new violation makes it harder to trust the data is safe.
Medicaid officials wrongly shared millions of people’s data with ICE, who passed it to Palantir. A judge allowed limited sharing but paused it after mistakes. More accidental shares were found, copies remained, and the state lawyers say ICE shouldn’t get more data until it can handle it safely. A hearing is set for August.
Q: What is Medicaid?
A: Medicaid is a government health program that helps people with low income pay for medical care.
Q: Who is ICE?
A: ICE stands for Immigration and Customs Enforcement — the officers who handle immigration and deportation.
Q: What is Palantir?
A: Palantir is a tech company that analyzes big piles of data. It made an app called ELITE that ICE uses to map addresses of people who might be deported.
Q: Why are the state lawyers worried?
A: They fear private health data of citizens and legal immigrants isn’t safe because ICE keeps finding copies of data it was told to delete.
Q: What happens next?
A: A judge will hold a hearing in August to decide what data sharing is allowed and clear up the confusion.