11
Trade Bombshell: Orioles Open to Moving Holliday, Cowser
Baltimore Orioles at the Trade Deadline: A Simple Guide to What Might Happen
Where Things Stand Right Now
Imagine your baseball team is like a student who got a C+ on their midterm. They’re not failing, but they’re not getting honors either. That’s the Baltimore Orioles right now.
The Report Card:
- Record: 52 wins, 55 losses
- In their division: 11 games behind the first-place Tampa Bay Rays (that’s a lot)
- In the Wild Card race: Only 2 games out of a playoff spot (that’s close!)
What’s a Wild Card?
Think of it like a "second chance" ticket to the playoffs. Even if you don’t win your division, the best runners-up get in. The Orioles are right there — just two games back.
What’s coming up: They’re playing the Detroit Tigers (also having a meh season) right now, then the Philadelphia Phillies (who are pretty good) for three games right before the trade deadline.
Two Paths: Buy or Sell?
With less than a week until the deadline, the Orioles are standing at a fork in the road. They could go either direction depending on how the next few games go.
Path A: They Lose → Become "Sellers"
If they slide further down the standings, they might trade away rental players — guys who become free agents after this season.
Potential rentals on the move:
- Taylor Ward (outfielder)
- Trevor Rogers (pitcher)
What’s a "rental"?
A player whose contract ends after this season. Contending teams "rent" them for a playoff push, giving up prospects in return.
Path B: They Win → Become "Buyers"
If they string together some wins, they might add players to chase that Wild Card spot.
The Most Likely Path: "Let’s Keep Our Options Open"
The article says it’s unlikely they’ll be big sellers. Instead, they’re doing what smart teams do: talking to everyone about everything to see what’s possible.
The Big Names Being Discussed (But Not Necessarily Shopped)
ESPN’s Jeff Passan reports the Orioles have had conversations with other teams about three of their best young players. This doesn’t mean they’re definitely trading them — just that they’re listening.
Jackson Holliday — The "Can’t-Miss" Prospect Who’s Finding His Groove
The Basics:
- Age: 22 (turns 23 this offseason)
- Draft: #1 overall pick in 2022
- Status: Was the #1 prospect in all of baseball before debuting
- Contract control: 4 more years after this season (through 2029)
The Story So Far:
Holliday got hurt in spring training (hamate fracture — a small bone in the wrist that really messes with hitters). He didn’t debut until mid-May. June was rough. But look at the last three weeks:
| Stat | Last 3 Weeks (50 plate appearances) |
|---|---|
| Batting Average | .410 |
| On-Base % | .520 |
| Slugging % | .487 |
| Walks | 10 |
| Strikeouts | 8 |
| Chase Rate (swinging at bad pitches) | 16.3% (super low!) |
Translation: He’s seeing the ball really well right now. He’s not going to hit .410 forever, but the approach is elite.
Why teams want him:
- Plays 2B, SS, and 3B (super versatile)
- 4 years of cheap team control
- Massive upside if he puts it all together
Why the Orioles might not trade him:
- Selling now = selling low (his overall stats still look meh: .243/.354/.392)
- No clear replacement at 2B (Jeremiah Jackson is struggling)
- They’d need a huge return — like controllable starting pitching
Colton Cowser — The Toolsy Outfielder Who Can’t Figure Out Lefties
The Basics:
- Age: 26
- Draft: #5 overall pick
- Contract control: 3 more years (through 2029)
- Defense: Really good in center field this year (4 DRS, 4 OAA)
The Rollercoaster:
| Year | BA / OBP / SLG | HR | K% | Notes |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2024 | .242 / .321 / .447 | 24 | 30.4% | Looked like a building block |
| 2025 | .196 / .269 / .385 | — | ~36% | Hit tool broke |
| 2026 | .207 / .315 / .332 | — | — | Hot May, cold since |
The Platoon Problem:
- vs Righties: .219 / .312 / .402 (103 wRC+ = league average)
- vs Lefties: .200 / .270 / .349
What’s a platoon?
Only playing a guy against pitchers he hits well. Cowser should probably only play vs right-handed pitchers.
Why he’s a more "natural" trade candidate:
- Hasn’t locked down an everyday role
- Still has tools (speed, arm, range)
- Another team might bet on the 2024 version returning
Orioles’ OF depth if he goes:
- Dylan Beavers (looking okay in small sample)
- Prospects: Nate George, Ike Irish, Enrique Bradfield Jr.
- Reed Trimble (on 40-man, near-ready)
- Free agents this winter: Randy Arozarena, Ian Happ, Seiya Suzuki, etc.
Adley Rutschman — The Face of the Franchise (Currently Injured)
The Basics:
- Elite catcher, controlled through 2027
- Currently on the Injured List
- Backup catcher Samuel Basallo is also hurt
Reality Check:
With both catchers injured, trading Rutschman right now makes zero sense. If he gets moved at all, it’d be in the offseason — not this week.
Why Trading These Guys Is Complicated
The "No Obvious Replacement" Problem
| Position | If Traded… | Current Backup Plan |
|---|---|---|
| 2B (Holliday) | Jeremiah Jackson (.248/.268/.393) | Maybe move Jordan Westburg from 3B? |
| OF (Cowser) | Beavers + prospects (not MLB-ready) | Sign a free agent this winter |
Control = Gold
"Controlled through 2027/2029" means the team pays them near-minimum salary for years. That’s incredibly valuable. You don’t give that up for spare parts.
The Pitching Context
The Orioles have some pitching locked up:
- Kyle Bradish
- Shane Baz
- Dean Kremer (only through 2027)
But beyond that? Lots of question marks. If they trade hitters, they’d want controllable starting pitchers back.
The Bigger Picture: A Core That Hasn’t Fully "Popped"
The Orioles were supposed to be a juggernaut by now. Their young core — Holliday, Cowser, Coby Mayo, Dylan Beavers, Jordan Westburg, Adley Rutschman, Gunnar Henderson — has shown flashes but not consistent dominance.
| Player | Status |
|---|---|
| Gunnar Henderson | Star-level at times, "just very good" at others |
| Adley Rutschman | Same — elite peaks, solid regular floors |
| Jordan Westburg | Good when healthy, but elbow surgery = throwing issues |
| Heston Kjerstad, Cade Povich | Top prospects, minimal MLB impact so far |
The front office has to decide: Is this group a championship core that needs time — or one that needs shaking up?
What Happens Next? (Step by Step)
- Play the next 4 games (vs Tigers, vs Phillies)
- See where they stand on deadline day (July 31)
- If close to Wild Card → Maybe add a reliever or bench bat
- If fading → Move Ward/Rogers for prospects
- Regardless → Keep talking to teams about Holliday/Cowser just in case
- Re-evaluate everything in the offseason — that’s when bigger moves (Rutschman? Holliday?) become realistic
IMPORTANT CALL OUT
Talking ≠ Shopping.
Every team calls every other team this time of year. "We discussed Jackson Holliday" ≠ "Jackson Holliday is on the block." It’s due diligence — doing your homework.
Summary
- The Orioles are stuck in the middle: 2 games out of playoffs, 11 back in division.
- Next 4 games likely decide if they buy, sell, or stand pat.
- Rentals Ward & Rogers are the only likely trade-outs if they sell.
- Holliday & Cowser are being discussed but would need massive returns to move.
- Rutschman isn’t going anywhere with two catchers hurt.
- The organization is keeping all doors open — for now, and for the offseason.
- The bigger question: Does this young core just need time, or a makeover? Answer coming soon.
FAQ
1. What is the trade deadline, exactly?
It’s the last day (July 31) teams can trade players without them clearing waivers. After that, trades are much harder. It’s like the "trade window" closing in fantasy sports — but for real.
2. Why would a team trade a #1 prospect like Holliday?
Two reasons: (1) They need immediate help (like pitching) and think they can win now, or (2) They’ve lost faith in the player’s development. The Orioles are in neither camp right now — which is why the price would be sky-high.
3. What does "controlled through 2029" mean?
The team owns the player’s rights for that many seasons at pre-free-agent salaries. It’s like having a coupon for 4 years of cheap, high-quality labor. Teams hoard this.
4. What’s a "hamate fracture" and why does it matter?
It’s a break in a tiny wrist bone (the hook of the hamate). For hitters, it kills power and bat control. Recovery can take months, and effects can linger. Holliday’s recent tear suggests he’s finally past it.
5. Could the Orioles actually make the playoffs?
Yes! They’re 2 games back with ~55 games left. A hot streak (like 10-3) puts them right in it. But they need to start now — hence the next 4 games being so critical.
