11
3 Teams That MUST Acquire Rockies Slugger Hunter Goodman
Hunter Goodman: The Power-Hitting Catcher Who Might Be on the Move
Hey there baseball fans! The Colorado Rockies are having a rough season (tied for the worst record in baseball at 42 wins and 67 losses). But they have a secret weapon that other teams really, really want: Hunter Goodman.
Goodman isn’t just any catcher—he’s a two-time All-Star who hits the ball really far, and he’s under team control through 2029. That’s like finding a rare Pokémon that stays on your team for years!
Let’s break down why contenders are calling Colorado, and which three teams make the most sense.
Who Is Hunter Goodman? (The Simple Version)
IMPORTANT POINT
Hunter Goodman = Elite Power Hitter + Average Defender + Team Control Through 2029Think of him like a video game character with maxed-out "Power" stats but middle-of-the-road "Fielding" stats.
- Position: Catcher (also plays 1st base, right field, left field)
- Age: Young enough to be a long-term piece
- Contract Status: Controlled by Rockies through 2029 (no free agency soon!)
- 2026 All-Star: Yes — his second straight All-Star appearance
- 2025 Silver Slugger Winner: Best offensive catcher in the American League last year
Goodman’s 2026 "Video Game" Numbers (Through July)
| Stat | What It Means | Goodman’s Rank |
|---|---|---|
| 31 Home Runs | Balls hit out of the park | #1 among ALL catchers (tied #3 in ALL of MLB!) |
| .545 Slugging % | How often he hits for extra bases (doubles, triples, HRs) | #1 among catchers |
| .871 OPS | On-base % + Slugging % = total offensive value | Elite |
| 17.0% Barrel Rate | % of batted balls hit perfectly on the sweet spot | 97th percentile (top 3% of MLB!) |
| 5 Multi-HR Games | Games with 2+ home runs | Includes two 3-HR games! |
ELI5 DEFINITIONS
- Slugging Percentage: Like a "power score." Singles = 1, Doubles = 2, Triples = 3, HRs = 4. Divide by at-bats. Higher = more extra-base hits.
- OPS: On-Base % + Slugging %. The best single number for "how good is this hitter?"
- Barrel Rate: Statcast tracks balls hit with perfect exit velocity + launch angle. 17% is insanely good.
Why Are Good Teams Calling the Bad Rockies?
Simple: Contenders need offense from the catcher spot. Most teams get zero production from their catchers. Goodman changes that instantly.
The Rockies have no reason to keep him — they’re rebuilding. Contenders have every reason to get him — he’s a difference-maker for a playoff push and years beyond.
The Three Best Trade Fits
1. Boston Red Sox
Current Record: 57-51 (Wild Card spot, winners of 20 of last 23!)
Why It Makes Sense
- Offense has slumped — tied for 28th in HRs (104), 24th in runs (454), 22nd in slugging (.393)
- Current catchers (Narváez, Wong, Gasper): Combined 5 HRs, 33 RBIs
- Goodman would be a MONUMENTAL upgrade — 31 HRs vs. 5 HRs from the position
Why Boston Might Say "No Thanks"
- Team chemistry is great right now — 20 wins in 23 games!
- Pitcher-catcher continuity matters — current catchers know the staff
- Goodman’s defense is below average (more on this later)
2. Texas Rangers
Current Record: 55-54 (1st place in AL West — only winning team in division!)
Why It Makes Sense
- Catcher production has been AWFUL:
- Kyle Higashioka: .218/.306/.370
- Danny Jansen: .171/.277/.309
- Backups Díaz & Wynns: no help
- Goodman would instantly become their most dangerous hitter
- AL West is winnable — Goodman could build separation
Why Texas Might Hesitate
- Are they true contenders or just "best of a bad division"?
- Goodman’s defense — teams may see him as a future 1st baseman/DH, not a long-term catcher
- Trade cost — is he worth a big prospect package if he moves off catcher?
3. New York Yankees ← THE BEST FIT
Current Record: Not stated, but clearly in win-now mode
Why This Is The Perfect Match
| Yankees Need | Goodman Provides |
|---|---|
| Power from catcher | Best hitting catcher since prime Gary Sánchez |
| Injury replacements | Aaron Judge, Cody Bellinger, Giancarlo Stanton all OUT |
| Elite power bat | 31 HRs, .545 SLG, 97th %ile barrel rate |
| Lineup protection | Adds another feared hitter to a dangerous lineup |
Smart Usage Plan (Managing His Defense)
- Start Goodman at C, Wells at DH — max offense early
- Late innings (lead): Swap → Wells catches (7 DRS), Goodman to DH/bench
- When Stanton returns: Goodman = Primary DH vs. LHP, Wells catches more
- Flexibility: Goodman can play 1B/OF too!
What NYY Could Offer Colorado
TRADE PACKAGE IDEA
- RHP Luis Gil — 2024 AL Rookie of the Year!
- RHP Elmer Rodriguez — promising young arm
- C Ali Sánchez — MLB-ready catcher depth
- + other prospects
Why Colorado says yes: Gil & Rodriguez join Rockies rotation immediately — no waiting!
Why NY says yes: Both pitchers blocked in NY (deep rotation), but starters in COL.
The Elephant in the Room: Goodman’s Defense
IMPORTANT CALLOUT: THE DEFENSIVE REALITY
Goodman is NOT a Gold Glove catcher. Every team knows this.
- -1 Defensive Runs Saved (tied 57th among catchers)
- 10 runners caught stealing (tied 21st)
- 29 starts in RF, 10 at 1B, 5 in LF — Rockies already move him around!
Translation: He’s a bat-first catcher who can fake it behind the plate, but you will hide him late in games or move him to 1B/DH long-term.
This is WHY the Yankees fit best — they have Austin Wells (7 DRS!) to spell him defensively.
Summary: What We Learned
- Hunter Goodman is a UNICORN — elite power-hitting catcher with 4+ years of control
- Rockies are sellers — 42-67 record = rebuild mode
- Three teams make sense:
- Red Sox: Need offense, but chemistry is rolling
- Rangers: Need catcher help, but division is weak
- Yankees: PERFECT FIT — desperate for power, have defensive backup plan, trade chips match up
- Defense is the only knock — but manageable with creative usage
- Yankees have the pieces (Gil, Rodriguez, Sánchez) that Rockies need NOW
FAQ: Your Questions Answered
Q: Wait, Goodman has 31 HRs as a catcher? That’s insane, right?
A: YES. For context: The entire Red Sox catching trio has 5 HRs combined. Goodman has 6x more HRs by himself. He’s on pace for ~45 HRs — historic for a catcher.
Q: What does "under control through 2029" mean?
A: It means the team that trades for him doesn’t have to worry about him becoming a free agent and leaving after this year. They get him for this playoff run + 3-4 more full seasons at a predictable (team-friendly) cost.
Q: Why would the Yankees trade Luis Gil? He was ROY last year!
A: Great question! The Yankees have a logjam of starting pitchers (Cole, Rodón, Schmidt, Warren, etc.). Gil has no clear path to the rotation in NY. In Colorado? He walks into the rotation today. It’s a "surplus for need" trade.
Q: Can Goodman actually catch every day?
A: Probably not ideal. The smart play (especially for Yankees) is platoon/late-inning swap: Goodman catches early (his bat in lineup), Wells catches late (his glove saves runs). Or DH Goodman vs. lefties. Flexibility is key.
Q: When would a trade actually happen?
A: MLB Trade Deadline is July 31st. With the Rockies terrible and contenders needing help, expect serious talks in late July. Yankees have the most urgency (injuries) and best matching pieces.
FINAL THOUGHT
Hunter Goodman is the rare "rental who isn’t a rental" — impact bat now, team control later. The Yankees have the need, the plan, and the pieces. Don’t be surprised if he’s wearing pinstripes by August 1st!
